Score: 8

"Can't... stop... giggling..."

submission: Arrgh Idol

date: September 29, 2009

And I'm still lol'ing. Short, but very nice!

Score: 8

"Saw will never be the same again"

submission: School 13 - H.S. - Saw 2

date: August 29, 2009

"...Nyet!" I knew it was coming, but I still lol'd XD

Score: 10

"I cried!"

submission: There She Is!! final step

date: December 27, 2008

What an amazing finale to such a powerful series! congratulations!

Score: 6

"Nice melody, some things could change."

submission: JOTS - Ghost City

date: December 18, 2009

The piano often gets off-tempo from the rest of the music and for some reason the guitar feels a little out of place. Perhaps you could build up to it and add some more hints that it should belong. However, I do like the piano piece itself and the melody is neat. Keep working at it :)

Score: 8

"Add strings"

submission: Reasoner- Living Transparent

date: September 29, 2009

I think the soft part at the beginning is just a tad too long, and you could add strings in there, mostly violins. Also where the pitch climbs, put in trumpets or maybe French horns. Put in quiet bass strings at the end, with long steady notes. Maybe even make the piano a minor part. The melody is lovely, but I do see what you mean when you say that this could be expanded upon.

Score: 8

"Reminds me of my webcomic..."

submission: Justice day

date: August 18, 2009

This totally reminds me of a scene that I'm putting in a webcomic of mine. I'll pm you the link when it gets drawn :) I like the song, but I think it could use a few more instruments, to make it sound fuller, if you know what I mean. The melody is excellent, though, and the transitions, though abrupt, are placed very nicely.